Air Fryer VS Toaster Oven | Comparison Guide

Regarding innovative kitchen appliances, air fryers and toaster ovens lead the charge. But how do they differ, and which suits your culinary needs best? 

Dive into this comprehensive guide to gain a clearer understanding.

What is an Air Fryer?

Air fryers have revolutionized our cooking by providing a healthier alternative to traditional frying. They circulate hot air around food to create a crispy, “fried” exterior without needing copious amounts of oil. 

This technology allows you to enjoy your beloved fried foods with a portion of the calories, making air fryers popular amongst health-conscious individuals.

What is a Toaster Oven?

Toaster ovens are compact, versatile appliances designed to toast, bake, broil, and roast food. With their convection feature, toaster ovens ensure an even heat distribution, resulting in perfectly cooked meals. Some modern models also offer an air frying feature, adding to their multipurpose appeal.

Air Fryer Vs. Toaster Oven: Comparison Guide

Air Fryer Vs. Toaster Oven

Air fryers are perfect for people who love fried food but want a healthier lifestyle. They’re generally more compact, making them suitable for smaller kitchens. However, their size can also be a disadvantage when cooking for larger families or parties.

Toaster ovens offer greater versatility in cooking styles and capacity. They’re a boon for baking enthusiasts or those who frequently roast or broil. However, they can consume more counter space, and are equipped with an air frying function necessary to replicate the ‘fried’ texture that air fryers excel in.

Can an Air Fryer Replace a Toaster Oven?

Whether an air fryer can replace a toaster oven depends on your cooking habits. A toaster oven is indispensable if you primarily toast, bake, and broil. 

However, an air fryer could suffice if you’re more into frying and grilling. An air fryer won’t toast as effectively as a toaster oven, and conversely, a toaster oven without an air frying function won’t match the ‘fried‘ results of an air fryer.

Can an Air Fryer be Used as a Toaster?

While some multifunctional air fryers have a ‘toast‘ setting, they sometimes produce different results than a traditional toaster or oven. 

You can still toast bread in an air fryer, but it might achieve a different crunchiness or evenness than a dedicated toaster.

Do I Need a Toaster and an Air Fryer?

If you enjoy a wide range of cooking styles and often cook for a larger crowd, having both appliances could be beneficial. 

However, if kitchen space or budget is a constraint, opt for the one that aligns more closely with your cooking habits. You can easily find the best affordable air fryers that can replace many appliances in your kitchen, or you may want to consider a modern toaster oven with an air frying function.

Air Fryer Vs. Toaster Oven Cooking Times

Air fryers typically cook faster than toaster ovens due to the rapid air circulation technology. However, this speed can vary depending on the quantity and type of food. Toaster ovens may take longer but can handle larger quantities of food items.

Air Fryer Vs. Toaster Oven – Comparison Chart

Here’s a quick comparison between Air Fryers and Toaster ovens.

AspectAir FryerToaster Oven
Cooking TechnologyRapid Air Circulation and Convection HeatingRadiant Heating or Convection Heating
Cooking MethodUtilizes hot air to circulate and cook foodUtilizes radiant heat to cook food
Food TextureEvenly Cooked resultsProvide a variety of textures
PreheatingFasterTakes longer to heat up
Cooking CapacitySmallerLarger
Energy ConsumptionEfficientConsume more energy
Other functionsGenerally has preset cooking functions and timersSome models have Broiling
VersatilityUsed for frying, roasting, baking, grillingCan do a wide range of cooking tasks
BudgetMore affordableVary with brands and models

Please note that the differences can vary between different models and brands of air fryers and toaster ovens. Please read reviews, check product description, or refer to the Air Fryer Mag for more details.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is an air fryer better than a toaster oven?

The answer to this question depends on your specific cooking needs. If your primary goal is to enjoy healthier ‘fried’ foods with less oil, then an air fryer might be your better option. However, a toaster oven could serve you better if you desire more versatility in your cooking methods, including baking, broiling, roasting, and toasting.

Should I get a toaster oven if I have an air fryer?

If you already have an air fryer that meets all your cooking needs, you may not need a toaster oven. However, if you often bake, roast, broil, or toast and want an appliance that can handle larger quantities of food, a toaster oven would be a worthwhile addition to your kitchen.

Does an air fryer use less electricity than a toaster oven?

In general, air fryers are more energy-efficient than toaster ovens. They heat up faster and cook food more quickly, which can save on electricity. However, the exact energy usage can vary based on the model, size, and cooking time.


Whether an air fryer or a toaster oven suits you better depends on your unique culinary needs and lifestyle. We have tried to make a detailed comparison and give you deep insights on Air fry vs. toaster ovens.

Evaluate the functions, capacities, and other features of both before making your decision. Rest assured, both appliances are designed to enhance your cooking experience and broaden your culinary horizons.

Leave a Comment